MISFITS Views

Moulin Rouge Review
by Tim Wick

I have seldom, if ever, seen a film more theatrical than Moulin Rouge. At the same time, the film is the most elegant justification for its own medium than I have seen in a long time. Director Baz Luhrmann (Strictly Ballroom, Romeo + Juliet) has succeeded in creating a modern musical that recalls the great MGM musicals of the 50's (if they were on speed and perhaps a little bit of acid).

Luhrmann uses familiar music lyrics as dialogue, which makes the transitions into song almost natural, be he knows that the conceit of breaking into song is, at it's core, just a little silly. He expects us to laugh when he presents us with an elaborately choreographed version of Madonna's Like a Virgin. If we didn't, he would be sorely disappointed. And laugh I most certainly did.

But I also marveled at the lush visuals of this film. The movie is made to be looked at, to be immersed in. Lavish sets and costumes are everywhere. Not to impress, but to draw you into the marvelous world that is Moulin Rouge.

It is stunning that a film so artificially constructed can seem so real. Camera shots, sound effects and dialogue constantly remind us we are watching a film but somehow we don't care. The theatre melts away and we are transported to a place of dreams.

The previews for this film do not make it terribly apparent that this film is a musical. The characters break into song so naturally, it is simply an extension of their speech. Ewan Macgregor's tenor gives the earnest lover Christian a childlike quality while Nicole Kidman's Santine sings with a throaty soprano that seems to wish for the days when she was as innocent as Christian.

The film will tell you that it is about Truth, Freedom, Beauty and above all Love. What a perfect description. Nothing but the most broad terms can capture what this broad film is about. It is larger than it's actors, it's script and even it's director. It soars so high that when it crashes, it is as if you have been buried under the whole of Mont Marte.

The basic story (and it is basic - as all musicals must be) is a story of love between a beautiful courtesan Satine (Kidman) and a poor writer Christian (MacGregor). Their love is challenged by The Duke (Richard Roxborough) who has convinced the owner of the Mulin Rouge (Jim Broadbent) to give Satine to him in exchange for funding a play Christian has written. This is all you need to know - in fact you don't need to know it. The story is simply a hanger on which the film is draped.

The songs in this film are all familiar but they have been altered (even twisted in the cast of the Police's Roxanne) to fit the visual and auditory styles of the film. Some songs aren't immediately recognizable and when you realize what they are singing, you giggle because the film pulled one over on you again. In particular, a love song montage is so over the top it's delightful.

To say that I loved this film is an understatement. I have not seen a movie more capable of touching me since Magnolia. I am certain that it is not for everyone. Some of it's extravagances are a little much (although I firmly believe that was the point).

Moulin Rouge may well be the most gutsy and original work to have found it's way on screen in the last several years. Because of that, I think it will be a challenge for this film to find an audience. It is also possible that the audience will grow as people like me find this film and drag their friends to showing after showing. Make no mistake, this film is a masterpiece. This film loves the medium of FILM as much as every film should. In a perfect world, Moulin Rouge would be the yardstick by which all musicals to come are measured.

 

Views Home Page

Calculating God Review: One of the novels up for Hugos. (05/31/2001)

Memento Review (05/29/2001)

Shrek Reviews: A pair of reviews about this ogre-meets-princess tale... (05/29/2001)

MISFITS at Marscon: We've got to have our party. (05/17/2001)

A Knight's Tale Review: I knew Queen and David Bowie have been around for a long time, but the middle ages? (05/17/2001)

amazon.com

iGive

Home




Moulin Rouge
* * * * *
Five Beakers
(out of five)

Based on his belief that people coming to this site give a rip about his opinion, you have probably guessed that Tim Wick has a pretty big ego. Despite having no experience as a critic, he insists on writing these boorish reviews of movies in a vain attempt to feel more important. Since it allows us to put up new material on the site and keep you all coming back for more, we go ahead and humor him.

We don't know anything about Tim's past. We assume that he just walked out of the west like Cain in Kung Fu, but we don't really care. He is a member of the board of directors for MISFITS and runs the read the book/see the movie club.

Or so he claims...

You can also read Tim's Memento Review

Search This Site


Copyright © 2001 MISFITS. e-mail:info@misfit.org
url: http://www.misfit.org
1437 Marshall Avenue, Suite 203
St. Paul, MN 55104